How to Give Feedback Effectively (With Examples Included)

By Indeed Editorial Team

Published 13 December 2021

Whether you're a manager or entry-level employee, being able to give effective feedback can be an essential skill to have in the workplace. Through feedback, you can help your colleagues and team members improve their work abilities. Understanding how to give feedback can help you give others actionable advice in the workplace. In this article, we explain why knowing how to give feedback is important and share steps to help you get started.

Related: The Importance of Positive Feedback and How to Deliver It to Others

How to give feedback

Below you can find a comprehensive step-by-step guide on how to give feedback:

1. Know why you're giving feedback

It can be a good idea to be clear on exactly what you intend to achieve by giving feedback. For annual or quarterly meetings, for example, you can consider specifically what you may like the person to work on before the next meeting. When you know what you want each person to get out of the feedback, you can be better able to lead the conversation in that direction.

2. Plan the timing

When giving feedback, it can be important to consider the timing. If you notice someone make an error or do something especially good, you can acknowledge this immediately. This way, your feedback can be fresh in their mind and they can make quick changes to their performance or keep up the good work.

Related: How to Give (and Accept) Constructive Criticism

3. Create a routine

If you're in a leadership position, you can schedule regular performance reviews for your team. Many companies choose to do this on a quarterly, bi-annual or annual basis. Having this feedback scheduled ensures that everyone gets a chance to discuss their performance in detail. This may also be a good time to give raises, offer promotions or set goals.

4. Frame the feedback with an invitation

Before giving constructive criticism, it can be beneficial to prepare your recipient for the meeting. Doing this allows them to get in the right mindset for your discussion. If you're going to give them feedback in person, you may consider sending them an email or direct message first. If you want to give someone praise, you may not necessarily need to preface it with an invitation, though you may want to if you want to discuss your praise in detail.

5. Prepare the feedback

Before giving your recipient feedback, it can be helpful to take some time to plan what you want to say. You can use a notebook to write some bullet points outlining your feedback. If you're giving feedback on areas to improve, you can consider actionable steps you can help your team member follow. If you're giving positive feedback, you may like to think about which specific skills or accomplishments of theirs you admire.

6. Make it personal

It's usually beneficial to consider the person getting the feedback as you think about how you want to present it. As you work with someone, you can observe what motivates and discourages them. You can take advantage of personal indicators to phrase or frame your feedback in an individualised and appropriate way.

7. Say what you mean

Try putting your feedback in the simplest possible terms, and consider practising what you're going to say. Being straightforward and honest can help you avoid misunderstandings and create trust. It helps to be specific about an incident or behaviour, whether positive or negative. When someone knows that a specific action is helpful or unhelpful, they can change their behaviour more easily.

8. Put the feedback in context

You can show how your feedback fits in with larger personal and organisation-wide goals. This helps people understand the reasoning behind the feedback. Seeing the results of the action or issue can also help motivate people to take the feedback seriously and be proactive in preventing similar shortcomings in the future.

9. Give specific examples

It can be a good idea to explain your points about a person's performance in a way they can measure and act upon. By providing specific examples when offering feedback, the person receiving the feedback can have a better idea of what to improve on and how.

Example: 'Our team has met our new sales goal this quarter for the second consecutive time. Your personal number of new customer phone sales during this time was excellent and we thank you for your contribution to our team's result. We encourage you to maintain your momentum. By continuing to keep your sales numbers consistently high, I believe improving your statistics from last year by 20% during this financial year can be very achievable for you.'

10. Keep your feedback balanced

Mixing positive and corrective feedback can make constructive criticism easier for people to accept. A technique that can help with this is to consider the feedback from the recipient's perspective. Recognising success can be a powerful motivator, as can hearing specific things to improve, but they're often most effective when used together.

11. Make feedback a conversation

Active listening can help feedback to make more of an impact. As you give feedback, you can allow time for the person to ask any questions they may have. When people have opportunities to explain or talk about their performance, they may feel more involved and can take responsibility for their actions and successes. For example:

  • How can I help you improve your sales stats for the next quarter?

  • Is this a fair representation of what happened at that meeting, or do you have a different take?

  • What would you like to share about my performance?

Related: The Main Components of the Communication Process

12. Create a feedback-friendly environment

When you make feedback a normal part of an organisation's operations, receiving feedback can become less stressful and create a more transparent work environment. As you invite others to receive feedback, you can also encourage them to ask for feedback. You may like to research healthy ways to process feedback and share them with your team. You can also consider adding different forms of feedback to your company's processes, like a 360 feedback process or a weekly survey.

Read more: 360 Performance Reviews: What They Are and How They Work

13. Evaluate the effects of your feedback

Giving feedback is a skill and can improve with practice as you see what works and what doesn't. Revisiting the topic after giving feedback can help you understand your own proficiency at giving feedback and gauge how effective it was for the receiver. Keeping records of individual goals and feedback meetings can make it easier to track progress and changes.

Positive feedback example

Here is an example of positive feedback you might give:

'Hi, Jane. I just wanted to thank you for your extra effort lately. Our team really appreciates the extra time you have put into your projects. Your work has made all of our jobs easier, and the client is really happy with our results. Due to your success on this project, I would highly suggest you apply for the management position at our firm. I think this promotion would be an excellent advancement in your career, and I would give you a good referral.'

Negative feedback example

Here is an example of negative feedback you might give to help someone improve:

'Hello, Steve. I'm hoping we can arrange a time to meet to discuss your recent performance. I've noticed that you've been coming to work late and leaving early. Is there anything you'd like to discuss to help me understand your recent performance? I want to help you create an employee performance plan to help you manage your time, as we love having you on the team.'

Related: What Are the Responsibilities of a Supervisor?

Why is knowing how to give feedback important?

Knowing how to give feedback can be important for the following reasons:

  • Improves productivity: When your colleagues know what skills they can improve, they can enhance their performance in the workplace. If a member of your team often misses deadlines, for instance, you might offer them feedback to improve their time-management skills.

  • Boosts morale: Giving your team members positive feedback can be just as important as giving constructive criticism. By identifying others' strengths, you can help them feel more confident in their work which can promote higher morale and job satisfaction.

  • Facilitates communication: Rather than assuming someone may notice their own shortcomings or strengths, feedback gives you the chance to communicate these things. You can also create open communication by asking others for their feedback about your performance.

Explore more articles